LA SUPERCLASSIFICA song by song
Posted: 11 May 2020, 13:34
Per ravvivare la conversazione, voglio proporvi quanto un utente di un altro forum aveva avuto in tema Genesis, in apparenza un esercizio monumentale quasi da "mission impossible" o da gran mal di testa per la spremitura di meningi (così la consideravo dopo averla letta, ma dopo attenta riflessione mi ci sono messo d'impegno anch'io fino a stilare la mia personale classifica) ovvero l'analisi dello opera omnia GENESIS stilata brano per brano in ordine di preferenza decrescente;
quella che segue è la mia personale classifica… chi legge è autorizzato ad analizzarla e criticarla finchè desidera, e perché no, magari a proporre la sua.
01 Supper's Ready………………………………………………………Foxtrot
02 The Musical Box……………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
03 The Cinema Show…………………………………………………Selling England by the pound
04 Dancing with the Moonlit Knight………………………………Selling England by the Pound
05 Firth of Fifth………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
06 The Fountain of Salmacis…………………………………………Nursery Cryme
07 Can-Utility and the Coastliners…………………………………Foxtrot
08 The Return of the Giant Hogweed……………………………Nursery Cryme
09 Watcher of the Skies…………………………………………………Foxtrot (RIGOROSAMENTE versione inclusa di INTRO)
10 Get 'Em Out by Friday………………………………………………Foxtrot
11 The Lamia……………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
12 Seven Stones…………………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
13 Looking for Someone……………………………………………………Trespass
14 The Chamber of 32 Doors……………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
15 The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
16 The Knife………………………………………………………………………Trespass
17 Blood on the Rooftops……………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
18 Mad Man Moon………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
19 The Battle of Epping Forest………………………………………… Selling England by the Pound
20 Robbery, Assault and Battery………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
21 Entangled………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
22 Dance on a Volcano………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
23 After the Ordeal……………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
24 The Carpet Crawlers………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
25 Hairless Heart…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
26 Ripples……………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
27 Fly on a Windshield……………………………………………………… The Lamb lies down on Broadway
28 Broadway Melody of 1974………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
29 Twilight Alehouse………………………………………………………… 45g 1973 (facciata B di "I Know what I like")
30 Stagnation………………………………………………………………………Trespass
31 The Colony of Slippermen………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
32 All in a Mouse's Night………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
33 Lilywhite Lilith…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
34 One for the Vine………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
35 Anyway……………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
36 Visions of Angels………………………………………………………………Trespass
37 In the Cage………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
38 Squonk………………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
39 Duchess……………………………………………………………………………Duke
40 Unquiet Slumbers for the Sleepers…………………………………Wind and Wuthering
41 I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)……………………………Selling England by the Pound
42 Los endos……………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
43 Me and Sarah Jane……………………………………………………………Abacab
44 A Trick of the Tail………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
45 Cul-De-Sac…………………………………………………………………………Duke
46 Time Table…………………………………………………………………………Foxtrot
47 Harlequin………………………………………………………………………… Nursery Cryme
48 For Absent Friends……………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
49 Duke's Travels……………………………………………………………………Duke
50 Duke's End…………………………………………………………………………Duke
51 ...In That Quiet Earth'……………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
52 Eleventh Earl of Mar………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
53 White Mountain………………………………………………………………Trespass
54 The Light Dies Down on Broadway…………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
55 Dusk…………………………………………………………………………………Trespass
56 Not About Us……………………………………………………………………Calling All stations
57 The Lady Lies…………………………………………………………………And then there were three
58 Harold the Barrel……………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
59 Guide Vocal………………………………………………………………………Duke
60 Behind the Lines………………………………………………………………Duke
61 Burning Rope……………………………………………………………………And then there were three
62 Inside&Out…………………………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
63 Here Comes the Supernatural Anaesthetist…………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
64 Many Too Many………………………………………………………………And then there were three
65 In the Beginning……………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
66 Riding the Scree……………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
67 Alien Afternoon……………………………………………………………Calling All stations
68 Cuckoo Cocoon………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
69 In the Rapids…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
70 Horizons…………………………………………………………………………Foxtrot
71 Please Don't Ask………………………………………………………………Duke
72 Grand Parade of Lifeless Packaging……………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
73 Back in N.Y.C.………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
74 Counting Out Time…………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
75 Home by the Sea……………………………………………………………Genesis
76 it………………………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
77 Abacab……………………………………………………………………………Abacab
78 There Must Be Some Other Way……………………………………Calling All stations
79 One man's fool………………………………………………………………Calling All stations
80 Down and Out…………………………………………………………………And then there were three
81 Afterglow………………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
82 Aisle of Plenty………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
83 Second Home by the Sea………………………………………………Genesis
84 Ravine……………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
85 In Limbo…………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
86 Wot Gorilla?……………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
87 Calling All Stations…………………………………………………………Calling All stations
88 Driving the Last Spike……………………………………………………We can't Dance
89 Deep in the Motherlode…………………………………………………And then there were three
90 Fading Lights…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
91 Pigeons……………………………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
92 Undertow…………………………………………………………………………And then there were three
93 Say It's All Right Joe………………………………………………………And then there were three
94 Snowbound………………………………………………………………………And then there were three
95 Heathaze…………………………………………………………………………Duke
96 Dodo/Lurker……………………………………………………………………Abacab
97 The Brazilian……………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
98 Man of Our Times……………………………………………………………Duke
99 Alone Tonight…………………………………………………………………Duke
100 Misunderstanding…………………………………………………………Duke
101 Another Record………………………………………………………………Abacab
102 Where the Sour Turns to Sweet……………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
103 Turn It On Again………………………………………………………………Duke
104 The Serpent……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
105 Hold on My Heart……………………………………………………………We can't Dance
106 The Conqueror…………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
107 Am I Very Wrong?……………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
108 Living Forever…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
109 Throwing It All Away………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
110 Uncertain Weather…………………………………………………………Calling All stations
--------------------------------CALDERONE DELLE MEDIOCRITÀ--------------------------------
Happy the man…………………………………………………………45g side A 1972
Window………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
Silent Sun……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
One Day………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
In the Wilderness………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
A Place to Call My Own………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
In Hiding……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
More Fool Me………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
The Waiting Room……………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
Silent Sorrow in Empty Boats…………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
Your Own Special Way………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
Match of the Day………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
Scenes from a Night's Dream………………………………………And then there were three
Follow You Follow Me…………………………………………………And then there were three
Ballad of Big ………………………………………………………………And then there were three
No Reply at All……………………………………………………………Abacab
Keep It Dark…………………………………………………………………Abacab
Like It or Not………………………………………………………………Abacab
Man on the Corner……………………………………………………Abacab
Who Dunnit?………………………………………………………………Abacab
Mama…………………………………………………………………………Genesis
Taking It All Too Hard………………………………………………Genesis
Silver Rainbow……………………………………………………………Genesis
Illegal Alien…………………………………………………………………Genesis
It's Gonna Get Better…………………………………………………Genesis
That's All……………………………………………………………………Genesis
Just a Job to Do…………………………………………………………Genesis
Tonight, Tonight, Tonight…………………………………………Invisible Touch
In Too Deep…………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Domino………………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Invisible Touch……………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Anything She Does………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Land of Confusion………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Since I Lost You…………………………………………………………We can't Dance
No Son of Mine……………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Dreaming While You Sleep…………………………………………We can't Dance
Jesus He Knows Me……………………………………………………We can't Dance
Way of the World………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Tell Me Why…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Never a Time………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
I Can't Dance………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Congo……………………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
Shipwrecked…………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
If That's What You Need………………………………………………Calling All Stations
Small Talk……………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
The Dividing Line…………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
quella che segue è la mia personale classifica… chi legge è autorizzato ad analizzarla e criticarla finchè desidera, e perché no, magari a proporre la sua.
01 Supper's Ready………………………………………………………Foxtrot
02 The Musical Box……………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
03 The Cinema Show…………………………………………………Selling England by the pound
04 Dancing with the Moonlit Knight………………………………Selling England by the Pound
05 Firth of Fifth………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
06 The Fountain of Salmacis…………………………………………Nursery Cryme
07 Can-Utility and the Coastliners…………………………………Foxtrot
08 The Return of the Giant Hogweed……………………………Nursery Cryme
09 Watcher of the Skies…………………………………………………Foxtrot (RIGOROSAMENTE versione inclusa di INTRO)
10 Get 'Em Out by Friday………………………………………………Foxtrot
11 The Lamia……………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
12 Seven Stones…………………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
13 Looking for Someone……………………………………………………Trespass
14 The Chamber of 32 Doors……………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
15 The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
16 The Knife………………………………………………………………………Trespass
17 Blood on the Rooftops……………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
18 Mad Man Moon………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
19 The Battle of Epping Forest………………………………………… Selling England by the Pound
20 Robbery, Assault and Battery………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
21 Entangled………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
22 Dance on a Volcano………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
23 After the Ordeal……………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
24 The Carpet Crawlers………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
25 Hairless Heart…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
26 Ripples……………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
27 Fly on a Windshield……………………………………………………… The Lamb lies down on Broadway
28 Broadway Melody of 1974………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
29 Twilight Alehouse………………………………………………………… 45g 1973 (facciata B di "I Know what I like")
30 Stagnation………………………………………………………………………Trespass
31 The Colony of Slippermen………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
32 All in a Mouse's Night………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
33 Lilywhite Lilith…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
34 One for the Vine………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
35 Anyway……………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
36 Visions of Angels………………………………………………………………Trespass
37 In the Cage………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
38 Squonk………………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
39 Duchess……………………………………………………………………………Duke
40 Unquiet Slumbers for the Sleepers…………………………………Wind and Wuthering
41 I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)……………………………Selling England by the Pound
42 Los endos……………………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
43 Me and Sarah Jane……………………………………………………………Abacab
44 A Trick of the Tail………………………………………………………………A Trick of the Tail
45 Cul-De-Sac…………………………………………………………………………Duke
46 Time Table…………………………………………………………………………Foxtrot
47 Harlequin………………………………………………………………………… Nursery Cryme
48 For Absent Friends……………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
49 Duke's Travels……………………………………………………………………Duke
50 Duke's End…………………………………………………………………………Duke
51 ...In That Quiet Earth'……………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
52 Eleventh Earl of Mar………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
53 White Mountain………………………………………………………………Trespass
54 The Light Dies Down on Broadway…………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
55 Dusk…………………………………………………………………………………Trespass
56 Not About Us……………………………………………………………………Calling All stations
57 The Lady Lies…………………………………………………………………And then there were three
58 Harold the Barrel……………………………………………………………Nursery Cryme
59 Guide Vocal………………………………………………………………………Duke
60 Behind the Lines………………………………………………………………Duke
61 Burning Rope……………………………………………………………………And then there were three
62 Inside&Out…………………………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
63 Here Comes the Supernatural Anaesthetist…………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
64 Many Too Many………………………………………………………………And then there were three
65 In the Beginning……………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
66 Riding the Scree……………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
67 Alien Afternoon……………………………………………………………Calling All stations
68 Cuckoo Cocoon………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
69 In the Rapids…………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
70 Horizons…………………………………………………………………………Foxtrot
71 Please Don't Ask………………………………………………………………Duke
72 Grand Parade of Lifeless Packaging……………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
73 Back in N.Y.C.………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
74 Counting Out Time…………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
75 Home by the Sea……………………………………………………………Genesis
76 it………………………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
77 Abacab……………………………………………………………………………Abacab
78 There Must Be Some Other Way……………………………………Calling All stations
79 One man's fool………………………………………………………………Calling All stations
80 Down and Out…………………………………………………………………And then there were three
81 Afterglow………………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
82 Aisle of Plenty………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
83 Second Home by the Sea………………………………………………Genesis
84 Ravine……………………………………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
85 In Limbo…………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
86 Wot Gorilla?……………………………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
87 Calling All Stations…………………………………………………………Calling All stations
88 Driving the Last Spike……………………………………………………We can't Dance
89 Deep in the Motherlode…………………………………………………And then there were three
90 Fading Lights…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
91 Pigeons……………………………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
92 Undertow…………………………………………………………………………And then there were three
93 Say It's All Right Joe………………………………………………………And then there were three
94 Snowbound………………………………………………………………………And then there were three
95 Heathaze…………………………………………………………………………Duke
96 Dodo/Lurker……………………………………………………………………Abacab
97 The Brazilian……………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
98 Man of Our Times……………………………………………………………Duke
99 Alone Tonight…………………………………………………………………Duke
100 Misunderstanding…………………………………………………………Duke
101 Another Record………………………………………………………………Abacab
102 Where the Sour Turns to Sweet……………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
103 Turn It On Again………………………………………………………………Duke
104 The Serpent……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
105 Hold on My Heart……………………………………………………………We can't Dance
106 The Conqueror…………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
107 Am I Very Wrong?……………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
108 Living Forever…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
109 Throwing It All Away………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
110 Uncertain Weather…………………………………………………………Calling All stations
--------------------------------CALDERONE DELLE MEDIOCRITÀ--------------------------------
Happy the man…………………………………………………………45g side A 1972
Window………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
Silent Sun……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
One Day………………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
In the Wilderness………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
A Place to Call My Own………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
In Hiding……………………………………………………………………From Genesis to Revelation
More Fool Me………………………………………………………………Selling England by the Pound
The Waiting Room……………………………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
Silent Sorrow in Empty Boats…………………………………The Lamb lies down on Broadway
Your Own Special Way………………………………………………Wind and Wuthering
Match of the Day………………………………………………………Spot the Pigeon EP
Scenes from a Night's Dream………………………………………And then there were three
Follow You Follow Me…………………………………………………And then there were three
Ballad of Big ………………………………………………………………And then there were three
No Reply at All……………………………………………………………Abacab
Keep It Dark…………………………………………………………………Abacab
Like It or Not………………………………………………………………Abacab
Man on the Corner……………………………………………………Abacab
Who Dunnit?………………………………………………………………Abacab
Mama…………………………………………………………………………Genesis
Taking It All Too Hard………………………………………………Genesis
Silver Rainbow……………………………………………………………Genesis
Illegal Alien…………………………………………………………………Genesis
It's Gonna Get Better…………………………………………………Genesis
That's All……………………………………………………………………Genesis
Just a Job to Do…………………………………………………………Genesis
Tonight, Tonight, Tonight…………………………………………Invisible Touch
In Too Deep…………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Domino………………………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Invisible Touch……………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Anything She Does………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Land of Confusion………………………………………………………Invisible Touch
Since I Lost You…………………………………………………………We can't Dance
No Son of Mine……………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Dreaming While You Sleep…………………………………………We can't Dance
Jesus He Knows Me……………………………………………………We can't Dance
Way of the World………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Tell Me Why…………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Never a Time………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
I Can't Dance………………………………………………………………We can't Dance
Congo……………………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
Shipwrecked…………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
If That's What You Need………………………………………………Calling All Stations
Small Talk……………………………………………………………………Calling All Stations
The Dividing Line…………………………………………………………Calling All Stations